Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature
-
yes, must stay for sure. Those are grate. Those crafty lines discribing death are gereat too!
-
I think I can speak from a lot of people's perspective on behalf of the CGN folk, the Tombstones were a killer addition and we all loved them, it added a bit of extra comedy to the game that everyone from all levels of skill participation enjoyed. I'd like for them to be an option, or see some use in the future.
-
I think a slightly more serious image, to match the look and feel of the game, would be required. Otherwise, I think it's a fun addition that should be added.
-
Does it make sense to have a ACU wreck instead of a stone tombstone? I know the ACU explodes in a big bang but if all my 2000 best faf friends are willing to suspend disbelief on the ACU chasis being able to withstand a nuclear explosion well enough to leave a blackened wreck I won't argue against it. But yes, nice function, let's keep it.
"Design is an iterative process. The required number of iterations is one more than the number you have currently done. This is true at any point in time."
See all my projects:
-
@Balfron said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
I think a slightly more serious image, to match the look and feel of the game, would be required. Otherwise, I think it's a fun addition that should be added.
That's a fair comment. I reckon making tombstones that fit each faction's design language is doable (UEF: Blocky, Cybran: Angular, Aeon: Round/Curved, Seraphim; Asymmetric). It is more work though and I have 0 knowledge on making models myself, unfortunately.
@IndexLibrorum said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
Does it make sense to have a ACU wreck instead of a stone tombstone? I know the ACU explodes in a big bang but if all my 2000 best faf friends are willing to suspend disbelief on the ACU chasis being able to withstand a nuclear explosion well enough to leave a blackened wreck I won't argue against it. But yes, nice function, let's keep it.
The only concern I can think about regarding an ACU wreck is that it can be confused for reclaim at a glance, depending on how it is implemented. Do we have ACU wrecks in the game files by default?
Thanks for all the comments so far, guys!
-
@Razana There is definitely an acu wreck I've seen somewhere for uef at least.
-
It could be added as a ranked sim mod
-
Some short thoughts and clarifications.
@Razana said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
because it gives that little bit of utility
Would you like more explicit death messages, like "was TMLed by Razana" or keep the more silly current tone?@Strydxr said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
I'd like for them to be an option
@BlackYps mentioned in Discord that making them a lobby option would make them only appear in custom games. Not necessarily a bad thing just something to keep in mind.
@IndexLibrorum said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
Does it make sense to have a ACU wreck instead of a stone tombstone
Fairly easily done, my concern with ACU wrecks is it might imply to people they have a mass value and they should fight over the reclaim.
@Razana said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
I reckon making tombstones that fit each faction's design language is doable (UEF: Blocky, Cybran: Angular, Aeon: Round/Curved, Seraphim; Asymmetric). It is more work though and I have 0
I considered this when making the initial model/texture but ultimately I waited too long to get started on April Fools stuff and decided to make one Tombstone better instead of 4 (even more) poorly made ones.
@Razana said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
Do we have ACU wrecks in the game files by default?
Yes, I'd need to check if they exist for every ACU but even if not I'm pretty sure they're just ACU meshes shaded like wrecks.
Oh! You know what would be cool? ACU wrecks that have the ACU kneeling like the GC while building. Doesn't solve the "looks like reclaim" issue but maybe that's less of a problem than I'm making it out to be.
-
@TheWeakie said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
It could be added as a ranked sim mod
Oh sorry forgot about this one.
I made last year's April Fools stuff into mods. They're very difficult to fill games with because so many people have modded games filtered out. Also I tried to get them ranked but was unable to, that's up to Creative Team.
-
@TheWeakie said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
It could be added as a ranked sim mod
Its an idea but some people will filter out games with sim mods and others just ignore games when sim mods are enabled (especially as there is no way to see if a game is ranked or not - they will just assume its not).
Lobby option would be the best imo -
Could the people that want it as an option (I read that as "yes, but not in my games") please state why? This helps for a productive discussion to better understand what the controversial parts of the feature are
-
It simply doesn't match the vibe of the game, as such it shouldn't be the default option. Still, should be a way to use it in custom lobbies if one wishes so without de-ranking the game.
Otherwise imagine you buy the game and you see this random ass wacky tombstones the moment someone dies. Ain't what you signed up for boss.
-
For me, my preferred lines are the ones that explicitly state who the killer was, regardless of how the death occured. But the sillier ones aren't a dealbreaker for me.
--
There is definitely an aesthetic mismatch with the tombstones as-is. Although there are potential workarounds also being discussed in this thread.
If anyone else would want to chime in on why they think this should or should not be implemented. This is your chance, especially if its a point that hasn't been brought up yet.
-
The problem with tombstones was that they’re not reclaimable despite the game having the ACU wreck model by default
I don’t want them in the game but if I was to add them it would be mod of having acu wreck in the game
-
@IndexLibrorum said in Add the Tombstones from the 2025 April Fool's Update as a Permanent Feature:
Does it make sense to have a ACU wreck instead of a stone tombstone? I know the ACU explodes in a big bang but if all my 2000 best faf friends are willing to suspend disbelief on the ACU chasis being able to withstand a nuclear explosion well enough to leave a blackened wreck I won't argue against it. But yes, nice function, let's keep it.
Lore-wise ACU wreck is the dead Dostya
-
Do we even need a wreck? There is a large black crater already. Isn't the utility of the feature the map marker and the message?
-
Imo the tombstones are fun and if it's decided to keep them it doesn't bother me but I'd hate this to be overthought/overdone.
That old adage comes to mind, if it ain't broke don't fix it.
-
@BlackYps Figured it would make more sense than an actual tombstone. Can still give it the marker and quote. But I'm good with either, I just quite liked the feature and would love to see it come back.
-
I'm just trying to understand what exactly people like or dislike about the feature because we have:
- the actual tombstones
- the marker on the map
- the text that informs about who the killer was
- the text being funny
It's not an all or nothing situation where we have to take or leave the whole package
-
FWIW, we actually found these tombstones break the PhantomX mod's win conditions. When an ACU pops the rest of their forces don't disappear.
Didn't report it because we assumed they were reverting after this week.
Otherwise I don't have a horse in this race, but maybe another reason to make it optional.