'Princess Burke' Mapping tournament

[IndexLibrorum]

I am submitting Project Luminary.
All write-ups, sexy pictures, and related information in the thread.

I've written a general report on the process of designing the map, and also written up a tutorial on how to use Gaea for creating masks. I believe together, these two post more than satisfy the requirements for 'Documenting the road'.

[ovenman]

My submisions:
Sentons winter

burke crater battles

Extra details:
https://forum.faforever.com/topic/6208/burke-tournement-submissions

[IndexLibrorum]

@Jip Question about the grading: will the scores for all categories per judge be published? I think it would help a lot with learning which aspects were best received, and which need more thought in the future.

[Jip]

@IndexLibrorum Yes, they will be given separately when applicable.

@ovenman Please make sure / convince us that your maps meet the vault rules. And please pick one, you can only submit one map.

[Jip]

Humble reminder that you have less then 24 hours to submit or make changes to your submission. Tomorrow at 14:00 GMT + 2 I'll download the last version of each submission that is in the vault at that moment. We'll manually share that version with the other judges so that you can not make further changes after the deadline has passed.

[IndexLibrorum]

@jip I thought the deadline was set for today?

[Jip]

It mentions the 17th, but it doesn't mention the time zone. So I'm being generous and I'll wait until it is the 18th all over the world.

[ovenman]

@Jip

[TheCrimsonKnight]

I am submitting Domum de Viridi Populo.
All documentation is in the map's README, as I don't know how to make thread here xD. Sorry for the inconvenience! Also my PC won't take in-game screenshots so here's a render. Sorry again! .

[Jip]

@TheCrimsonKnight the readme is empty, see also:

[Jip]

The submission deadline has passed! Thank you to those that submitted, we're looking forward to grading them. We'll try to come back with the results as July starts.

For this tournament we're taking into account the following submissions:

• @Madmax with version 6 of the map Temple of Marxon
• @CaptainKlutz with version 2 of the map Rhizas Legacy
• @IndexLibrorum with version 3 of the map Project Luminary
• @TheCrimsonKnight with version 5 of the map Domum de Viridi populo

With a kind reminder to @TheCrimsonKnight to fix the readme in the upcoming few days. Reading on Discord it seems to me that you were trying but that something went wrong.

We will not take into account the following submissions:

• @ovenman See the general guidelines (5) and (6)

[TheCrimsonKnight]

@Jip idk where it went, I wrote it but maybe saved it somewhere weird and now I can't find it. therefore I forfeit (unless I can find it soon) because I don't have time to re-write it unless I'm allowed to later today. Sorry for wasting your time.

[TheCrimsonKnight]

UPDATE: I found it hiding in the v1 folder of the map, not sure if it's on the vault so I'll drop it in your discord DM's. Thank you for your time.

[MadMax]

@thecrimsonknight

@jip said in 'Princess Burke' Mapping tournament:

It is about sharing the knowledge to create content

the write up is supposed to be public if you want help making it a forum post just ask

[Jip]

I've received it and I'll make it public when we turn it into wiki pages.

[Jip]

We're almost done grading. We hope to finalize the grading by the 9th of July

[CaptainKlutz]

I've never been more excited to have my work roasted in my life

[IndexLibrorum]

Fun fun fun

[MadMax]

[Jip]

As promised a few days ago - here are the final results:

		Donum	Luminary	Marxon	Legacy
Points by Jip
Aesthetics		5,50	10,00	8,50	3,25
Gameplay		2,75	6,75	9,00	6,75
AI		5,50	6,25	9,00	7,50
Theme		5,25	9,00	3,50	6,00
Subtotal average:		4,75	8,00	7,50	5,88
Points by Resistance
Aesthetics		5,50	8,50	7,90	5,90
Gameplay		4,80	8,10	7,30	4,60
Theme		6,30	8,80	5,40	5,70
Subtotal average:		5,53	8,47	6,87	5,40
Points by Stormlantern
Aesthetics		7,00	9,00	7,00	8,50
Gameplay		4,00	4,50	5,00	4,00
Theme		4,50	8,50	7,50	8,00
Subtotal average:		5,17	7,33	6,50	6,83
Points by Deribus
Aesthetics		6,00	9,00	8,00	6,00
Gameplay		3,00	8,00	6,00	9,00
Theme		3,00	9,00	6,00	7,00
Subtotal average:		4,00	8,67	6,67	7,33
		Donum 4th	Luminary 1st	Marxon 2nd	Legacy 3rd
Total averaged points:		4,86	8,12	6,88	6,36

With congratulations to everyone that participated and in particular for @IndexLibrorum for being 1st and for @MadMax for being 2nd! You can contact me to get your reward. Because of the expenses surrounding the prize, please follow the following procedure to obtain it:

• (1) Send me (this account) a message in the forums with a random string such as a guid and the prize that you would like to have
• (2) Send me (jip839) a message in Discord with the same guid that you send me on the forums and the prize that you would like to have
• (3) After confirming the GUIDs, I'll share you my personal email address
• (4) Send me an email with the same guid that you send me on the forums and Discord along with the prize that you would like to have

From that point onwards I assume that the email address belongs to you. We'll then arrange the price through the email. As a final step I ask you to confirm receiving the prize over email, Discord and in this topic again. It may take a few days to go over this process as I do have a professional and personal life

There's a lot of feedback surrounding the submissions. At the moment these are still relatively raw. If you'd like the raw feedback then you can send me a message on the forums. Throughout next week we'll finalize the feedback and put it, together with all the resources you created, on the wiki. I'll make a new post when that is complete.