Hello everyone,
Since I would now like to consider this small project finished, I wanted to share a few final thoughts.
First of all, thank you very much for all the interesting comments under The Commissar's video!
The feedback and impressions were very diverse and highlighted many different perspectives. Some of them even brought up aspects I hadn't considered myself. This is exactly what makes community feedback so valuable.
Conclusion of the original project
I consider the original project – the improvements to the ACU walk animations – officially complete. I will keep the changes exclusively as a mod addition within my mod pack. I do not plan any further development or integration into the base game.
However, what I would particularly like to highlight is the way this project was presented.
I deliberately wanted to try different approaches to reach as many members of the community as possible and gather a wider range of opinions and feedback.
One of the reasons for this was my experience with the previous factory model project, where my approach and the opportunities for community participation apparently weren't equally clear to everyone.
Therefore, I decided to try several different communication channels for this smaller project (excluding a direct presentation on Discord).
Here is a brief summary of the results:
GitHub – 8 weeks of testing
I initially presented the project as a Pull Request on GitHub. Although I received some feedback, it was limited to two testers. There were also a few short clips included directly in the project.
Results:
Views: 2 / Responses: 2
FAF Forum – 6 weeks of testing
To encourage greater participation and gather more opinions, I subsequently presented the project here on the forum.
Results:
Views: 157 / Responses: 5
YouTube video – 1 week of testing
As a third approach, I asked The Commissar to create a video about the project.
In my opinion, the advantage of a video is that changes and their effects can be demonstrated quickly and clearly. This may also make it easier for people who aren't directly involved in the project to form their own opinions.
Results:
Views: 530 / Responses: 16
Final thoughts
I hope this small experiment has demonstrated some of the possibilities for improving communication with the community in the future.
Especially when it comes to changes and new ideas, it's important to gather as many different opinions as possible. Not only to identify potential improvements, but also to collect new suggestions and perspectives.
My personal conclusion is that it can definitely be worthwhile to explore alternatives to the traditional forum approach when presenting projects. Of course, this was only a small experiment and not a universal solution. Nevertheless, I hope that my experience might be useful for future projects or other proposed changes.
Thank you to everyone who took the time to look at the project and share their thoughts!
I wish you all the best and hope you have a great time! 