FAForever Forums
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Login
    The current pre-release of the client ("pioneer" in the version) is only compatible to itself. So you can only play with other testers. Please be aware!

    Are walled T1 PD useless now?

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Game Issues and Gameplay questions
    26 Posts 10 Posters 2.4k Views 3 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • R Offline
      Reckless_Charger
      last edited by

      See Duellists YouTube vid:
      https://youtu.be/AIe_160lwVY
      Which indicates they are useless now.

      Intended behaviour seems to be otherwise:
      https://github.com/FAForever/fa/pull/3415
      Where Tagada says
      'All of the PD's will now be similar in effectiveness to old Cybran/UEF ones.'

      Haven't tested it myself so what's the deal?

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • MadMaxM Offline
        MadMax
        last edited by

        the pd's were equalised that vid was old before it even got posted

        Vault Admin / Creative Team / Map Guru

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
        • B Offline
          badsmurf
          last edited by

          This is yesterday's video, and it says walls are equally useless now) So yet they a re balanced but now they are a trap of wasting mass and doing nothing)

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • R Offline
            Reckless_Charger
            last edited by Reckless_Charger

            Well I guess all the non Seraphim players can also experience the joy of being overrun by nothing but tanks or having to put their PDs behind factories

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • ZeldafanboyZ Offline
              Zeldafanboy
              last edited by

              Don’t have time to watch the video but if this is true then this should be fixed ASAP

              put the xbox units in the game pls u_u

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • T Offline
                Tagada Balance Team
                last edited by Tagada

                It's very random but overall, it's pretty closely balanced. Unless we get a way to automate the tests then I can't provide anything better.
                https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1x9X8dVM0Wwlu34uCgFpyjB08yBs-wFa2A8-Lc0pAIyo/edit?usp=sharing

                To clarify:
                The UEF and Cybran PD should behave in the same way as before
                The Sera PD got a buff
                The Aeon PD got a nerf

                Now all of the PD's are exactly the same in terms of stats, any differences come from the fact that the engine is inconsistent when it comes to hitboxes.
                Relevant Github PR:
                https://github.com/FAForever/fa/pull/3415/files

                R 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • R Offline
                  Reckless_Charger @Tagada
                  last edited by

                  @tagada What's the result with no walls at all?

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • CheeseBerryC Offline
                    CheeseBerry
                    last edited by

                    The walls and PDs are, as far as I can tell, equal now. The weird findings from the duelist are the result of him testing the walls on completely flat ground.

                    He mentions that walls do nothing to protect t1 pds (on completely flat ground):
                    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AIe_160lwVY

                    I can reproduce his findings quite easily too:
                    https://youtu.be/y60-_oqdyFk

                    Interestingly though, on even slightly bumpy ground, walls are quite effective at protecting the pd:
                    https://youtu.be/fsAQEd7KQz4

                    So for all normal maps, walls and pds interact basically as you'd expect while on crazyrush etc. walls are completely useless at protecting a pd.

                    I'm assuming that was a weird accident, and not something done intentionally, @Tagada ?

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                    • T Offline
                      Tagada Balance Team
                      last edited by

                      That's how the PDs have always worked. The UEF PD was unchanged while the Cybran one was even slightly buffed. The main changes are making the sera one actually use walls and the Aeon one hittable at all.
                      My tests have also been made on flat ground and there is about 20-25% chance of the walle blocking some- significant amount of damage.

                      CheeseBerryC 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • CheeseBerryC Offline
                        CheeseBerry @Tagada
                        last edited by CheeseBerry

                        @tagada: I did a bit more testing and it seems walls on completely flat ground block basically no shots if the tank is at near maximum range, and basically all shots if the tank gets close enough to the pd. (See 15952938)

                        The exception seems to be the aurora, which always shoots over walls on flat ground, regardless of distance. (See 15952973)

                        Again, this doesn't matter on most (non-flat) maps where walls behave quite simply as you'd naively expect.

                        On completely flat maps, this highly range dependent behavior gives some neat strategic options. I like it, honestly.

                        Summary (for now?):

                        • On normal, non-pancake maps walling your PDs is good and works as you'd expect.
                        • On flat maps walling your PDs blocks shots of tanks getting close to it, so it's probably(?) still a good idea.Unless your opponent makes auroras, in which case walls do nothing.
                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • T Offline
                          Tagada Balance Team
                          last edited by

                          Look at the linked sheets with the tests performed on completely flat ground, Usually, the walls don't block shots but not always.

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • CheeseBerryC Offline
                            CheeseBerry
                            last edited by

                            I looked at the sheets and while the data is useful, they don't mention how exactly the tests were perfomed. That does seem to matter here though.

                            If my findings from the last post are correct, you'd always want to fight against pds on flat maps from as far away as possible, e.g. via using attack move, as walls only black shots from up close

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • T Offline
                              Tagada Balance Team
                              last edited by

                              The tests were performed on flat ground using an attack order targetting the PDs so the shots can be blocked by walls from far away.

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • CheeseBerryC CheeseBerry referenced this topic on
                              • CheeseBerryC Offline
                                CheeseBerry
                                last edited by CheeseBerry

                                While I have found angles where a wall on flat ground can block a tank shot fired from a distance, at least in my testing those are very rare.

                                Compare this test, where not one tank shot got blocked by a wall:
                                https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y60-_oqdyFk

                                or this one, where I drive around the pd in different distances:
                                https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03kWKjv8gxk

                                Note that in the latter test, some shots from far away are blocked by a wall, depending on the shooting angle. The vast majority are not though, unless you drive in closer, when all shots are blocked.

                                My only explanation is that we must be doing something slightly different afterall. I don't know what though. Ideas:

                                • Is "flat" ground not actually flat?
                                • Do tanks, or their turrets, sometimes spawn very slightly higher or lower?
                                • Has there been some, ostensibly, unrelated change somewhere else in the code that changed the tank-wall interaction?
                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • T Offline
                                  Tagada Balance Team
                                  last edited by

                                  I used Flat 1 mex map and it is flat
                                  They shouldn't
                                  Not that I am aware of, the only changes that were made to either tank or PD or wall files were the ones I made.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • ThomasHiattT Offline
                                    ThomasHiatt
                                    last edited by

                                    It was never consistent before and it still isn't consistent now. At least now it is equally inconsistent across factions. Mass cost and buildtime are pretty negligible for normal amounts of PD so you should still build them.

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • R Offline
                                      Reckless_Charger
                                      last edited by Reckless_Charger

                                      What's the aim here? Do we want walled PD which block all T1 tank shots or which are slightly porous (to a random degree). Has anyone looked at hit boxes of walls as well as PD?

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • T Offline
                                        Tagada Balance Team
                                        last edited by

                                        Yes it was looked at thoroughly and the desired outcome is close to the one we have right now, the Walls block some but not all shots, and all of the PDs behave (roughly) in the same way.

                                        ZeldafanboyZ R 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • ZeldafanboyZ Offline
                                          Zeldafanboy @Tagada
                                          last edited by

                                          @tagada

                                          I can't ever recall Cybran/UEF walled PD templates ever acting like this, if this is what the PD are being normalized to. It seems like at max range the walls block absolutely 0% of shots, not some percentage.

                                          put the xbox units in the game pls u_u

                                          T 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • W Offline
                                            wikingest
                                            last edited by

                                            If game calculates shell mouvement useing ballistic trajectory, or something similar. Then there are some logic in fact that shells/projectiles coming from far away get better over walls. Coming from far, shells draw much higher "arc", and at the moment of impact they are descending much more than when fired from close, with smaller "arc" and less drop.

                                            Drawing higher wall (hitbox) should block all shots. Eventually, after that, drawin narrower/irregular wall (hitbox), with "openings" in wall/between walls, could allow some of shots from different distances to pass. Maybe.

                                            Not saying that it is better in one or other way.

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                            • First post
                                              Last post