@PMBMizer and + 500 streamer points = 2453

@maudlin27 @Giebmasse @IndexLibrorum

Thanks for the answers.

I understand your position and why you cannot disclose this information.

My position is that any exceptions to the FAF rules should be public. It's logical and doesn't take much time.

This would help to avoid a lot of unnecessary requests for moderation.

Or at least instead of such an answer (which was received by several people at once) "Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We will investigate'
Moderators can tell the truth. "This is an old player, the previous account was deleted, and we allowed him to create a new one. Thank you for understanding and have a good game!"

@snoog I didn't ask questions that required endless discussion. But for some reason, no one can answer them.

@Giebmasse Im agree with Nuggets. Im not sure why faf privacy is being quoted here. Nobody is asking for personal information.

But if the player's nickname is private information, then I have 2 questions.

1. Should moderators delete my nickname history upon my request?
2. 
   If the answer to both questions is yes, then I have no other questions.

P.s.: I'm not asking the moderators to ban anyone.

@Jip I'm not asking for more or less bureaucracy. I ask the moderators to be consistent and logical.

If there are more rules, then for everyone, if there are fewer, then for everyone too. I agree that if the previous account is deleted, the player has the right to receive a new one.

But I still haven't heard a single reason why information about a past nickname should be a secret.

Hiding such information suggests that such players (there are several of them) were previously banned for cheats or smurfing. There's no other reason to hide anything. I'm not the only one who thinks so.

I am grateful for your answers and do not ask you to continue the dialogue if it is uncomfortable for you. I hope the moderator team will also respond with something.

@Jip Not so long ago, the moderators wanted to change the nickname once every six months, which the entire community was unhappy with. We don't allow nicknames like |||||| precisely because nicknames are important. This is the position of the community, which is written in the rules

@Jip I know games where a player can hide their nickname. For example WOT.

But that's not the point. I appreciate the decision. I don't appreciate secrets. If the situation is exceptional, the moderators can simply write about it so that it is public.

I don't see any good reason why one player can hide his past nickname, but the other can't. And I don't see any problems from the fact that information about his past will be public. It's not difficult, and it's honest.

The more secrecy there is, the more questions there are. Is not it so?

@Jip There are only 2 options.

1. Nicknames are not important. Then give all players the opportunity to be anonymous. So that the nickname is not visible
2. Nicknames are important, then don't make obscure exceptions.

There is no bureaucracy or complexity involved.

A very cool tournament! I am pleasantly surprised that 32+ participants in this rating range have registered. Congratulations to all the winners and prize-winners!

@Jip @Deribus I'm glad that some players are coming back (such a player is not 1, we all know that) I will be glad to see them in tournaments. But I believe that such decisions by the moderator team should be public. It is necessary to indicate his previous nickname in the profile of such a player. Or give all players the opportunity to be anonymous, hiding their nickname.

I don't see any valid reason for hiding this information.
P.s; I repeat. I'm not calling for anyone to be banned.

@waffelzNoob I have no objections. I'm just asking you to moderators to make a list of reasons why a player can get a new account. At the moment, there are no such reasons in the rules. Even hiding your nickname and changing it often is forbidden.

What could be the moderators' reasons for giving a player permission to create a new account?
We all know that FAF is played by players who had accounts before. We will not call them by nicknames and in no case ask anyone to ban them.
But I'm asking the moderators to add reasons to the rules based on which I can create a new account for myself.

I suggest introducing the ability in the client to delete requests for moderation. It happens that you misunderstand the situation or submit a request based on emotions. I think it would be easier for the moderation team if the player himself could delete an irrelevant query.

@Vindex ok, unfortunately I cant play on 12.07, Im out

@Vindex We have a lot of tournaments in July https://forum.faforever.com/post/67574

@Vindex btw https://forum.faforever.com/post/67906

in Skrat 1709