M28AI Devlog (v148)

maudlin27

v131 Update
28 changes and fixes, including:

8 adjustments for when M28 hits the unit cap, primarily focused on when ctrl-king its T2 units is not enough
Reduced M28's tendancy to overbuild aircraft carriers
Engineers should no longer suicide into enemies firing at them that it lacks radar coverage of
9 LOUD specific changes (including adding a workaround to allow prioritisation of fatboys) and 1 steam change (fixing a bug with T2 kennels not being upgradable)

Acknowledgements:

MrPhalanx – Mentioning T2 kennels couldn’t be upgraded in steam
RD – Bitterwind Crag, Elephant Rock and Mellow Shallows replays against v1.29
Vortex – Replay vs 1.30

maudlin27

v132 Update
21 changes, including:

Gunships should group together better, and take into account how successful they've been in the game with engagements when deciding whether to attack
Fixed some issues with transports that would e.g. prevent them dropping early when dying to inties
Reduced tendancy to build more factories late-game
10 LOUD related changes, including reviewing/tweaking various LOUD focused PRs from Azraeel (covering building more T3 PD, bombers, ecoing more, and changes to unit prioritisations)

Acknowledgements:

Azraeel - Various pull requests

MrPhalanx

Thanks anyway, I check the Ai again ..

maudlin27

v133 Hotfix - Summary
11 Changes and fixes, including:

M28 should no longer try and protect a friendly teammate's core base afer the teammate has been killed and their base destroyed
Changed how M28 prioitises which zones to request units/give them orders, to take into account enemy buildings (in theory making it slightly more likely to attack undefended enemy mexes over defending a friendly location)
Fixed a bug introduced in the last version for managing gunships that could sometimes break their logic
7 LOUD specific changes, including supporting factory enhancements, and updating the ACU threat assessment to take into account the ACU health and to account for the massively higher mass cost given to it in the blueprint (10k, which is almost 200 t1 tanks)

Acknowledgements

Vortex - several LOUD replays

maudlin27

v134 Update
Another 13 changes, including:

Greater focus on ecoing, with mexes being more likely to upgrade if held for a long time, while making it more likely mexes are prioritised over factories if stalling mass
ACU should be more likely to get high value reclaim near it if it's not in immediate danger, even if it would like to get a gun upgrade
Slightly reduced the amount of engineers to be built in cases where the zone has run out of assignments to give them relatively recently
4 LOUD specific changes, including fixing a bug that would result in lots of land factories upgrading at once, and reducing MML production where the enemy has TMD.

Acknowledgements
Vortex - A number of LOUD replays

v135 Update
Re-uploaded as I forgot to turn off some debugging options.

maudlin27

v136 Update
18 changes and fixes including:

Disabled some of M28's kiting logic if it has poor intel
Improved experimental targeting when faced with an enemy under shields (so they should focus down the shields first)
Fixed a bug that meant submarines wouldn't run from torpedo bombers
6 LOUD specific changes (Aeon land experimental preferences, and various gunship adjustments)

Acknowledgements

Vortex - several replays
Azraeel - Replay that highlighted the bug with subs not retreating
Kemi - Replay showing overbuilding of protector bots in LOUD
Waffelznoob - Replays of M28 being crushed, and crushing

v137 - Hotfix for a LOUD specific bug

Saver

Hello everyone, I have a little thought for amphibious units that move underwater. I can cite the GC as an example. When the AI uses this unit, I have often found that the unit will stall in the water on banks if enemies are too close to the water. The problem, however, is that submarines or other enemies with torpedoes also attack them and the GC makes no real attempts to save itself. Or rather take up the fight on land, where he also has weapons.

Unfortunately I have no idea whether this can be fixed. But oh man, what hasn't the M28 already accomplished

maudlin27

@saver Anything like that I’d need a replay to assess as there will be competing logic:
-Retreat to avoid damage from subs
-Avoid a cycle of retreating and advancing all while taking damage without doing anything
-Avoid making landfall to die to a superior force
-Avoid overreacting to a small naval threat

The logic will likely have room for improvement in specific scenarios

Saver

@maudlin27 Hi and thank you for your quick response. Unfortunately I don't have a replay right now. However, I could see it quite often in map like seton. If I have a good example, I'll be happy to pass it on. However, I play with my unit mod. and hope it's okay for you too.

maudlin27

v138 Update
13 changes, including:

Units should try and take evasive action from a nuke missile they can see approaching them
Fixed an issue that could cause far too many land scouts to be built
Adjusted when M28 builds factories and power generators to try and reduce cases where it can overflow mass
Fixed an issue with if M28 was given control of allies in Fort Clarke Assault it would take control of the starting Ahwassas once the cutscene ended
2 LOUD specific changes, including a workaround for the lack of an amphibious category for engineeres and ACUs

Acknowledgements

Hypoxic – Highlighting an error with fort Clarke
Vortex – Replay vs M28 that highlighted a few issues with M28 (overflowing resources, overbuilding land scouts, and some other smaller points)
RD - Replay

maudlin27

v139 Update
Introducing AI variants (something I've wanted to do from back when I was working on M27 but which kept being put off for more immediate/easier changes):

M28 Adaptive - Standard M28AI - will do what it thinks is best for the situation
M28 Air - Focuses mostly on air units with minimal land units
M28 Land - Focuses mostly on land units with minimal air units
M28 Rush - Similar to M28 land but tries harder to win without getting higher tech factories
M28 Tech - tries to get away with fewer factories and more aggressive tech upgrades
M28 Turtle - Relies far more on PD and T2 arti to stop enemy attacks in the T1-early T3 stage, although will still build a modest land and air force
4 other small changes, mostly relating to trying to make M28 build a greater variety of experimentals once it gets a paragon (in case the opponent can keep up with its GC spam without suffering much damage)

I expect the AI variants will need various tweaks over time so let me know if they do anything that seems odd given their described focus. They'll also still use units the same as M28AI, i.e. the main change with the variants is to what they build, not how they use the units they build.

MrPhalanx

Hi , another problem about the UEF T3 Kennel (Eng. Station). It now properly upgrades from T2 without any issue, but the auto-assist range STILL retains its T2 range(it shows how the T3 range should be, but the drones only autoassist when the thing what needs to be assisted is in around the T2 Kennel range, can you look into it?
Thx: Mr. P.

maudlin27

@MrPhalanx What are you playing on (e.g. is this still steam?), and have you tested with no mods other than M28AI, and then without M28AI (i.e. no mods), and confirmed that the auto-assist range is lower only when M28AI is enabled?

I can't think of anything obvious M28AI does that would impact such behaviour as it doesn't make changes to the kennel unit (other than UI related changes relating to the addition of the shared armies UI button, but I wouldn't expect a UI button to change auto-assist ranges)

MrPhalanx

Yeah Its still on Steam, then the only thing I can think about is some of the mods are changed it. I need to look into it, but I'm not exactly a pro in this field, just like to dabble here and there.

maudlin27

v140 Update
9 changes, including:

New M28 Random option - it will pick from one of the AI personalities (other than M28Easy) at the start of the game.
Fixed several bugs introduced in the last update relating to factories deciding what to build.
T3 mobile shields should be used similarly to shield boats when on water
M28Air should no longer rush an experimental as quickly as other M28AI (since it'd try rushing an air experimental, before it had even built asfs, in some cases)

Acknowledgements

Azraeel - LOUD replay
Vortex - LOUD replay and mentioning a potential M28 bug with player TMLs being paused

maudlin27

v141 Update
New M28Navy variant, which looks to get more naval units, including naval experimentals, at the expense of its land and air force.

4 other changes, including:

Fixing a bug when deciding what experimental to build
Atlantis shouldn't submerge if navy is won
Non-amphibious naval units (such as destroyers) should switch to attack-move when retreating and close to their destination, so they are less likely to turn their backs on an enemy that's attacking a nearby naval factory

Acknowledgements

Vortex - LOUD replay from v139

maudlin27

v142 Update
Smaller update fixing a few bugs:

Fixed an error with one of M28’s land factory builders that could prevent land factories building.
T1-T2 engineers should no longer be built at a core base when close to the unit cap with T3 engineers available.
Reduced the amount of T2 arti to be built in respect of a far away enemy threat (such as a fatboy) if we have a significantly stronger mobile force than the enemy.
Fixed a bug that meant M28’s logic for prioritising production due to the enemy having a greater mobile ground threat wasn’t working.
Fixed errors that could arise when M28 tried assisting a naval factory in a water zone with no naval factory.

Acknowledgements

Fearghal - Replay that prompted majority of the above changes

maudlin27

v143 Update

Mexes built in another player's core base should be more likely to be gifted over even if they're closer to M28 than that other player (e.g. maps like advanced pass)
Units should be less likely to engage long ranged threats/firebases
M28's shared armies UI button can be hidden via the game options
Fewer T1 arti should be built in response to T1 PD and at the early T2 stage
Fixed a bug and added a redundancy to M28's asf hover-micro

Acknowledgements

Wingflier – LOUD replay
Zeotile – noticing the M28 mod description doesn’t reflect that it’s compatible with LOUD or steam
Rhaelya – 2 replays fighting M28 on open palms, and highlighting the overbuilding of T1 arti

kagurazakanana

Hi Maudlin27,

First off, awesome job on the M28 AI mod—it keeps getting better with every update! Lately, I’ve run into a couple of issues and wanted to ask for your input.
I’ve noticed that the Overwhelm Rate, Overwhelm Interval, and Overwhelm Limit settings don’t seem to work as intended. From what I understand, these should gradually increase the AIX's cheat multipliers over time, but I haven’t seen any changes after adjusting these settings. I’m using game version 3984, with default options.
Another issue involves M28's strategy on large maps. We had a 3v3 on a 40km x 40km naval map with lots of resources (Peer Player, 16+ mass points each). We set up 3 M28 AIs with a 1.5*1.5 multiplier. We rushed to build a Paragon: Experimental Resource Generator at around 25 minutes, protected by 30+ shield generators, but M28 didn’t respond effectively and was eventually overwhelmed by approximately 10 Mavors.
By the late game, M28 AIX had relative air superiority with over a dozen T4 air units, but they remained idle around the base and didn’t prioritize key targets.
Lastly, I noticed M28 AIX had no defense against T3 bomber snipes on the ACU. On large maps, it seems vulnerable to such tactics, without strong countermeasures.
Do you have any suggestions or insights into these issues? Are these areas for potential improvement in future updates?

maudlin27

@kagurazakanana
Thanks for the feedback, in respect of your points:

AIx Overwhelm issues - I'm assuming you're playing with AIx M28, could you send me the replay ID where this doesn't work? Testing just now it's working as I'd expect.
40km 3v3 - If you send me the replay ID I can have a look at what it did for if there are any obvious improvements that could be made. I suspect given the map size and it being a naval map it was simply too slow to capitalise on its higher AIx modifier, since it may choose to invest heavily in navy (and I'm assuming the paragon was outside of naval range)
Not attacking with T4 air - This will depend on how much anti-air there is, so I'd need a replay to check whether it was being over-cautious
Bomber snipes - it should intercept strats with asfs (as well as having the ACU under a shield, with health upgrades, and SAMs). My guess would be this was on a 40km map and its air force was too far from the ACU when the strats were spotted (but if it had asfs and didn't even try to intercept the strats then send me the replay)