What are your favorite and least favorite maps to play in the matchmaker?

0

This question is to anyone who plays on the matchmaker (I'm on the matchmaker team, and I'd like to get more feedback).

Please also specify the maps' queue(s) (1v1, 2v2, 4v4) if you remember, since some maps can be fun to play with one player count but undesirable to play with another (ie: playing Seton's Clutch 1v1 is different from playing Seton's Clutch 4v4).

waiting for a mapgen-only TMM queue and Godot

3

From playing 4v4 TMM (1.1k rank)
Least favourite: Seraphim Glaciers
-Last game that started on it, the rest of my team all commented on how much they hated it. The main reason I dislike it is because games likely go on for ages and it seems to have featured in the map pool a lot.

Most favourite: Mapgen, since I dont have to worry as much about my team expecting me to play a particular way. I've not had enough games on all of the various maps in the pool, but if I was to pick one as favourite it'd probably be Falcon Stone River.

As a general rule I much prefer maps with no set 'roles', and maps that haven't seen loads of play (so are less likely to have an expected way to play the map), while I also tend to prefer non-20km naval maps since they usually take far longer to resolve.

M27AI developer; Devlog and more general AI development guide:
https://forum.faforever.com/topic/2373/ai-development-guide-and-m27ai-v66-devlog

2

My favorite 4v4 TMM maps:

  • Mangrove Delta
  • Forgotten Archipelago
  • Maridia
  • Metir

Basically, I love navy maps with an emphasis on frigate raids, t2 navy, and torps. These maps in particular are very much the sweet spot for me in terms of aggressiveness. Other navy maps like Headland, Lena River, Lost Archipelago or Saskiya are a bit too large/turtely for me. Still ok maps, but not great.

Good 4v4 land maps:

  • Monument Valley
  • Plateau of arracis (haven't played it much, but I enjoyed the 4v4 on it so far)

Here I like asymmetry, larger than 10x10 so TML and firebases arent too dominant, not some kind of winner-takes-it-all mex or reclaim distribution.

My least favorite 4v4 TMM maps:

  • Seraphim Glaziers (usually decided after 2 minutes by bomber vs transport)
  • Winding river (so much wrong here. River too long and narrow. Corners 100% contestable winner-takes-it-all. After winning mapcontrol and having 3x the eco the game drags out for another 30 minutes because you cant actually attack bases with land/navy)
  • Adaptive Kusoge (bottom 2 slots too open. 20x20 diagonal is just too big for a pure land map)
  • Sands of Ablicka (<2km rush distance on top lane and very contestable reclaim)
  • Syrtis Major (just awkward middle relcaim and lots of chockes)
  • Sirgis (too spread out, fucked side slots)
  • any very linear/lane-oriented and symmetric 10x10 land map
  • Seraphim outpost (basically 4 1v1s next to each other, with whoever wins his lane first then just dominating all other slots with air)
  • Delta river (too turtely)
  • Strife of Titan (you spwan like 1km away from an enemy in 4v4)

While compiling this list I came across a couple maps that should be considered for 4v4 tmm:

  • Turtle Beach
  • Adaptive Ocean Crater
  • Skadi
  • Krakens Nest
  • Madness -8-