In-lobby Auto Balancing

@thecore said in In-lobby Auto Balancing:

@emperor_penguin just tested it, the AutoBalance works well, however I think there could be bug where some players were not placed correctly (their positions in the lobby did not match their game positions). I was the host on gap map and I was front on team 1, then I auto balanced and I was moved to air team 2. However when the game started I was placed front on team 1 (not sure on the other players) can you confirm this?

I am not aware of a bug where the lobby positions don't match the in-game positions. If that happens when spawns are set to 'fixed', you can report it in the #game-bug-reporting channel on the FAF Discord. However, I imagine you might not have set spawns to 'fixed' (ie: you had opti enabled). I thought about it, and just made an additional PR to have clicking the AutoBalance button automatically set spawns to fixed.

@arma473 yes the host can fix it but I assumed the point of it all was to make the host's life easier. Ideally the balancer shouldn't mess with the auto teams setting at all and should be able to 'read the room' and make a proper 3v3 in a 4v4 lobby with 2 empty slots before this gets pushed out to everyone. People are gonna click that button early and for an inexperienced host the result could be quite confusing. First impressions matter.

I do love it though, don't get me wrong. I just think this is kind of an edge case the dev didn't immediately consider and the sort of thing testing is for. Just reporting my test results.

It is worth pointing out that even the existing optimal balance (mirrored) fails to do this right. A 4v4 launched with 6 players and 2 open slots does make a 3v3 but a different slot might be left open for each team, asymmetrically.

Would it be possible to hard-code positions information for some (10+) of the most popular maps that aren't organized this way?

In general, I'm guessing that all new maps tend to have alternating positions, so this would be a one-time effort without significant ongoing effort to maintain the list.

@arma473 said in In-lobby Auto Balancing:

Would it be possible to hard-code positions information for some (10+) of the most popular maps that aren't organized this way?

In general, I'm guessing that all new maps tend to have alternating positions, so this would be a one-time effort without significant ongoing effort to maintain the list.

You don't need to hardcore anything the balance should just respect the selected option of the teams like left vs right or top vs bottom or odd vs even. This way it is flexible enough to handle any map.

if it could go by whatever teams are assigned to the slots when you click the button that would be great. sort the spawn numbers per team and fill in order

@phong
FYI, the AutoBalance function was already set to use the slot-team combinations previously assigned if half of the occupied slots were set to team 1 and half to team 2. Otherwise, it was set to just remake the teams in alternating team order (1, 2, 1, 2, 1, 2, etc) for the occupied slots.

However, I understand your point about wanting to use odd vs even, top vs bottom, and left vs right AutoTeams; so, I just added functionality to support them to this PR. I had mixed thoughts on how to choose the order in which the slots will be filled with those AutoTeams. I tested out trying to have it sort by location, but between the different symmetry types and too many maps having inconsistent/imperfectly mirrored spawn locations, I wasn't satisfied with the results. So, I opted to set those AutoTeams configurations to just place people in numerical slot order, only skipping closed slots and slots necessary to skip to keep team size equal (if any). If there is an odd number of players with 1 of those configurations, it will make the last player an observer (or remove the player if it's an AI).

The previous functionality basically remains when AutoTeams are not set to odd vs even, top vs bottom, or left vs right. Additionally, if any of those configurations are set but yield an insufficient number of slots on one team, teams are set to a manual configuration to make an equal number of players on team 1 and team 2.

@arma473 While it is theoretically possible to hardcode things for individual maps, that is probably not the right approach for this. If there are some particularly important cases, you might want to talk to the map authors about fixing them (and or investigate getting FAF version of maps made if the authors are MIA/unknown).

thanks for the effort @Emperor_Penguin. I've been using it all day and I am very satisfied with it. It works great even as it is now if i close the open slots before clicking.

Reasons the new balance is better than old opti-balance:

Does better when grays are in the lobby

Does all the hard work but lets you tweak the result. On maps with rotational symmetry, I'd rather have strong players in the center lane and weaker players on the sides. Old opti sometimes made highest-vs-lowest rated machups on such maps. Your solution lets me fix this with 4 clicks

Not forced to re if the balance is only good on paper

Can accommodate premade teams easier. click button then swap some similarly rated players from one team to another

Would be cool to be able to lock some slots. "Me and my mate are on this team, now you balance the rest".

Slot based balancing would be cool too (matching similar slots against each other) but too tricky

The host has control over the lobby. The current solution gives the host full control.

@thecore said in In-lobby Auto Balancing:

@emperor_penguin just tested it, the AutoBalance works well, however I think there could be bug where some players were not placed correctly (their positions in the lobby did not match their game positions). I was the host on gap map and I was front on team 1, then I auto balanced and I was moved to air team 2. However when the game started I was placed front on team 1 (not sure on the other players) can you confirm this?

I've also experienced this bug just now. I used autobalance, then did 4 more swaps to fix lane balance. then someone said they had a premade, so i did one more swap, the last one. I was one of the players. This last swap didn't carry over to the game, instead, we spawned in the last position before this swap, which had also been set by a manual swap operations for each of us post autobalance.

I was using fixed spawns